maurice/snix
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

* The recent change in nixpkgs of calling `stdenv.mkDerivation'

Browse source 
instead of `derivation' triggered a huge slowdown in the Nix
  expression evaluator.  Total execution time of `nix-env -qa' went up
  by a factor of 60 or so.

  This scalability problem was caused by expressions such as

    (x: y: ... x ...) a b

  where `a' is a large term (say, the one in
  `all-packages-generic.nix').  Then the first beta-reduction would
  produce

    (y: ... a ...) b

  by substituting `a' for `x'.  The second beta-reduction would then
  substitute `b' for `y' into the body `... a ...', which is a large
  term due to `a', and thus causes a large traversal to be performed
  by substitute() in the second reduction.  This is however entirely
  redundant, since `a' cannot contain free variables (since we never
  substitute below a weak head normal form).

  The solution is to wrap substituted terms into a `Closed'
  constructor, i.e.,

    subst(subs, Var(x)) = Closed(e) iff subs[x] = e

  have substitution not descent into closed terms,

    subst(subs, Closed(x)) = Closed(x)

  and otherwise ignore them for evaluation,

    eval(Closed(x)) = eval(x).

* Fix a typo that caused incorrect substitutions to be performed in
  simple lambdas, e.g., `(x: x: x) a' would reduce to `(x: a)'.
This commit is contained in:
Eelco Dolstra 2004-03-30 15:05:35 +00:00
parent df101d6fca
commit c4ac2a164a
2 changed files with 11 additions and 2 deletions
Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

8
src/libexpr/nixexpr.cc
View file

@ -177,9 +177,13 @@ Expr substitute(const ATermMap & subs, Expr e)
ATMatcher m;
ATerm name;
/* As an optimisation, don't substitute in subterms known to be
closed. */
if (atMatch(m, e) >> "Closed") return e;
if (atMatch(m, e) >> "Var" >> name) {
Expr sub = subs.get(name);
return sub ? sub : e;
return sub ? ATmake("Closed(<term>)", sub) : e;
}
/* In case of a function, filter out all variables bound by this
@ -199,7 +203,7 @@ Expr substitute(const ATermMap & subs, Expr e)
substitute(subs2, body));
}
if (atMatch(m, e) >> "Function" >> name >> body) {
if (atMatch(m, e) >> "Function1" >> name >> body) {
ATermMap subs2(subs);
subs2.remove(name);
return ATmake("Function1(<term>, <term>)", name,